By Diana Hsieh
The Rocky Mountain News published a good letter on the "Miracle on the Hudson" on January 28th:
Credit pilot, not GodFor a more detailed analysis along similar lines, see Greg Perkins' post on NoodleFood.
Concerning US Airways Flight 1549, we are all elated that there were no deaths. However, several television stations reporting on the incident must have mentioned God more than 40 times as the reason everyone aboard survived.
Why don't we give credit to the real hero, the pilot? His quick thinking and calmness under duress saved many lives.
If there was a God involved, why would he have the plane crash to begin with?
We know that almost all air crashes involve most, if not all, passengers being killed. Do we ever invoke God when people are killed? A quick-thinking pilot and some luck saved all the lives on this particular flight.
Marc Tanenbaum, Longmont
A legal system -- particularly criminal or tort law -- cannot stand if God were seriously taken to the author of such events: everything would happen as a matter of God's perfect will, and so no person could regard himself as wronged by another. Unless, of course, God wanted you to right the wrong that he permitted to happen -- and then the law becomes an arbitrary game of guessing God's will.
The lesson? Capitalism cannot be grounded in religious faith.